The district court found that the “mansion loophole” cap on exemptions provided for in section 522(p) applies even in opt-out states where the debtor does not have the option to choose between state and federal exemptions. It also held that rule 4003(b)(4) does not impose a deadline on notice to the debtor of filing an objection to exemptions. In re Kane, No. 21-8209 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 2022). [Read more…] about Hockey Player Shoots but Doesn’t Score
3% Change In Debtor’s Income Not Enough for Modification
The bankruptcy court abused its discretion when it granted the trustee’s motion to modify the debtor’s chapter 13 plan to capture the $300.00/month the debtor saved when he refinanced his home loan where the change in the debtor’s financial circumstances was not “substantial” as a matter of law. Martinez v. Gorman (In re Martinez), No. 21-1077 (E.D. Va. June 16, 2022). [Read more…] about 3% Change In Debtor’s Income Not Enough for Modification
Exemptions for Joint Tenancy and Separate Living
The debtors were entitled to exempt only their one-half interest in one of the two residences where they owned both properties jointly but the husband lived in one residence and the wife lived in the other. They could avoid the creditor’s judgment lien to the extent the lien impaired those exemptions. In re Snyder, No. 21-31521 (Bankr. N.D. Ohio Sept. 23, 2022). [Read more…] about Exemptions for Joint Tenancy and Separate Living
Creditors Cannot Rely on Verbal Agreement to Extend Deadline
The creditors were not entitled to have the court vacate its order of discharge where they claimed their untimely objection was in reliance on a verbal agreement between the debtor’s counsel and the trustee to extend the deadline but the court never ordered any extension. In re Kharlanov, No. 22-70984 (Bankr. E.D.N.Y. Sept. 22, 2022). [Read more…] about Creditors Cannot Rely on Verbal Agreement to Extend Deadline
Servicer Sanctioned for Post-Foreclosure Dunning
The bankruptcy court did not err in finding the mortgage servicer violated the discharge injunction or in awarding over $10,000 in sanctions where the servicer continued to dun the debtor for payment after the debtor had received her chapter 7 discharge and relinquished the home in a foreclosure sale. Berry v. Fay Servicing, LLC, No. 21-8005/8007 (B.A.P. 6th Cir. Sept. 9, 2022). [Read more…] about Servicer Sanctioned for Post-Foreclosure Dunning
Mortgage Creditor Sanctioned for Miscalculating Claim
The debtor was entitled to attorney’s fees and a reduction in the mortgagee’s arrearage claim where the mortgagee failed to reduce the arrearage by the entire amount the debtor had paid in his prior chapter 13 bankruptcy. In re Simmons, No. 22-680 (Bankr. D. S.C. Aug. 31, 2022). [Read more…] about Mortgage Creditor Sanctioned for Miscalculating Claim
Wrongful Possession Does Not Confer Property Interest
“[A] debtor’s mere possession of a property, without a good-faith claim to it, does not save an installment contract for § 1322(c)(1) relief.” In re Peralta, No. 20-3496 (3rd Cir. Sept. 7, 2022).
The debtor bought his house on an installment contract rather than through a traditional mortgage. After he breached the contract, he and the seller entered into a new agreement where the debtor agreed to resume regular payments but if he defaulted again, the seller would exercise its right to get a judgment for possession, and the debtor would vacate the house. The agreement specified that a second breach would “extinguish[ ] any and all rights, liens, and/or interest” the debtor had in the house. [Read more…] about Wrongful Possession Does Not Confer Property Interest
Laches Forecloses Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss
Where the Trustee slept on her right to challenge the debtor’s method of calculating her plan payments until shortly before the debtor completed her plan, the doctrine of laches compelled denial of the trustee’s motion to dismiss. In re Melcher, No. 16-21536 (Bankr. E.D. Ky. Aug. 30, 2022).
The debtor and the chapter 13 Trustee negotiated a 60-month plan in which the debtor agreed to commit one third of her annual gross income over $120,000 to the plan (“excess income payments”). The debtor calculated her first excess income payment by taking the income from Box 1 of her W-2 form, subtracting $120,000 and multiplying the result by .33. After discussion with the Trustee and one of her creditors, the debtor’s payment was accepted as correct. The debtor used the same method of calculation for the following years’ excess income payments. [Read more…] about Laches Forecloses Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss
$1.7 Million Retirement Accounts Not Part of Estate
The court held its nose and slogged through the trustee’s lengthy complaint riddled with errors and legal misconceptions to find that the debtor’s retirement accounts totaling approximately $1.7 million were not property of the bankruptcy estate. McDonnell v. Gilbert (In re Gilbert), No. 21-12725, Adv. Proc. No. 22-1005 (Bankr. D. N.J. Aug. 23, 2022). [Read more…] about $1.7 Million Retirement Accounts Not Part of Estate
SG Agrees 10th Erred But Opposes Cert
Despite agreeing that the Tenth Circuit got it wrong, the Solicitor General for the United States filed a brief opposing certiorari in the case of Kinney v. HSBC Bank USA, No. 21-599 (brief filed Aug. 30, 2022). The issue was a simple one: whether the debtor could receive a completion discharge under section 1328(a) when she missed the final three payments on her mortgage due to a car accident, but made up the payments shortly after her plan expired. [Read more…] about SG Agrees 10th Erred But Opposes Cert