Where the Trustee slept on her right to challenge the debtor’s method of calculating her plan payments until shortly before the debtor completed her plan, the doctrine of laches compelled denial of the trustee’s motion to dismiss. In re Melcher, No. 16-21536 (Bankr. E.D. Ky. Aug. 30, 2022).
The debtor and the chapter 13 Trustee negotiated a 60-month plan in which the debtor agreed to commit one third of her annual gross income over $120,000 to the plan (“excess income payments”). The debtor calculated her first excess income payment by taking the income from Box 1 of her W-2 form, subtracting $120,000 and multiplying the result by .33. After discussion with the Trustee and one of her creditors, the debtor’s payment was accepted as correct. The debtor used the same method of calculation for the following years’ excess income payments. Read More
