Neither Pennsylvania nor the Third Circuit apply the doctrine of equitable subordination to reprioritize a junior lien over a modified senior lien. Hamilton v. Pa. Hous. Fin. Agy., No 18-5417 (E.D. Pa. March 5, 2020).
The debtors had a home mortgage for $145,000. They defaulted on their mortgage and applied for Homeowner’s Emergency Mortgage Assistance (HEMAP). Through that program, they entered into an open-ended mortgage with the Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency (PHFA) which operated as a line of credit with a principal of $51,000. PHFA then satisfied the mortgage arrearage and maintained the mortgage through April, 2013. In May, 2013, the then-current mortgage holder obtained a judgment of foreclosure against the debtors in the amount of $139,447.26. After that, the debtors and the mortgage assignee, entered into a modified agreement which the debtors later defaulted on. When the creditor sought to foreclose, the debtors filed for chapter 13 bankruptcy. PHFA filed a claim for over $18,000 and the mortgage creditor filed a claim for over $189,000. Because the mortgage lien exceeded the value of the property, the debtors moved the bankruptcy court to find the PHFA junior debt wholly unsecured under section 506(a). [Read more…] about No Equitable Subordination of Liens in Pennsylvania